Trainers · Balance 27 · Steam build 26572818
The Witch and her 15 Potions in 1.5.1
How the Witch's daily Potion works in 1.5.1, and when each Potion is worth its gold, your Item use and the risk of a random result.
Ranked data: 6 Nov 2026 to 19 Nov 2026, Balance 27.



The
Witch gives you one extra decision each day: the Potion in her first shop. A Potion is worth buying when it changes your next battle or your next merge more than the gold and the Item use would. Most of the risk comes from random targets. The table below checks each of the 15 Potions against that test, using the 1.5.1 catalog and rules.
How does the daily Potion offer work?
The Witch's text is short: the first shop rolled each day contains a Potion. The shop rules add the details.
- It is the first shop only. The Potion sits in the Item slot of the day's first shop. Any reroll swaps out every slot, the Item slot included, and no later shop that day counts as the first. Decide on the Potion before you reroll, or you lose that day's offer.
- Potions are a separate pool. There are 15 Potions, and only the Witch brings them. A normal Item roll never offers a Potion, so later shops that day can show other Items but no Potion.
- No immediate repeat. The Witch does not offer the previous day's Potion again when another Potion is possible. Do not plan on the daily offer repeating yesterday's Potion.
- Potion Pack blocks the lock. While a
Potion Pack shop is active, you cannot lock the shop. - A Potion uses your Item budget. You start each day with one Item use.
Mini Rainbow Potion,
Rainbow Potion and
Portal Potion give that use back when their effect lands. Potion Pack gives back the use of its own purchase, and the Potion you then buy from it uses the normal budget; after that purchase the Pack shop is discarded. The other Potions consume the use. Extra uses come from
Tote Bag (two for the day) and
Membership Card (one every day). - Useless Items are greyed out. The shop does not let you buy an Item that would do nothing.
All 15 Potions at a glance
Costs and effects come from the 1.5.1 catalog. The "buy when" and "skip when" columns are advice based on those effects, not on observed runs.
| Potion | Cost | Effect in short | Buy when | Skip when |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| $0 | +$10 | Nothing else needs today's Item use | A later shop is likely to need the use for a stronger Item | |
| $1 | Each of your monsters gets a small amount of Damage, Poison or Burn | You own several monsters; each receives its own buff | You own few monsters; the catalog gives no amount | |
| $10 | A random level 2 Common with no sell value | You have an empty team or bench slot and need a level 2 unit | Team and bench are full, or a random Common will not fit your plan | |
| $1 | Doubles the base sell value of all your monsters, sells them all, gives +1 shop rank and 8 free rerolls | Your board is failing and you can rebuild before Battle | Your board is winning | |
| $1 | One random monster with 2 or fewer types gains a random extra type; refunds the use when it works | A new type can only help your board | An extra type would break a "no shared type" condition | |
| $10 | You get a cheapest monster in the shop, levelled up | The cheapest offer is one you want, ideally a species you hold at level 2 | The cheapest offer is useless to you, or you have no empty slot | |
| $5 | +$5 for each life you have lost this run | You have already lost 2 or more lives | You have lost 1 life or none | |
| $1 | Every shop today includes monsters from other regions; refunds the use when it works | You want to look beyond your region's roster today | You are rolling only for copies of your own units | |
| $0 | One random monster turns SHINY | No other Item needs today's use, and every eligible unit's shiny form is acceptable | Today's use is needed elsewhere | |
| $10 | +30 Sell Value on each monster that has a sell value | You plan to sell soon, or to sell everything | You plan to keep the board | |
| $1 | Refunds its use and opens a shop for one Potion purchase | You want to choose a Potion instead of taking today's | You want to lock the current shelf before replacing it | |
| $1 | Every monster with 2 or fewer types gains a random extra type; refunds the use when it works | Type-count or type-target effects reward more types | Extra types would break a condition on your board | |
| $6 | Every monster in your shop this turn is SHINY | You will buy an offer and its shiny entry fits your plan | The shiny form would hurt the plan | |
| $5 | Fills empty team and bench slots with random Legendary monsters that have no sell value | You have many empty slots and a weak board | You still need bench room for copies that will not merge at once | |
| $5 | Rolls a shop of only species that are on your team and bench | You need one or two copies to finish a merge | You have no merges in progress |
Which gold and sell-value Potions are real profit?
Blood Potion pays only after real losses. It costs $5 and pays $5 for each lost life. You need 2 lost lives just to come out ahead. Never throw a battle to feed it: from day 5, one defeat takes 3 of your lives, and once
Second Chance is spent, the next time you reach zero lives the run is over. A few dollars cannot buy back that risk.
Fate Potion sells all your monsters, not one unit. A unit sells for about half its base cost times a level factor, and that factor grows from 1 to 3 to 6 as an ordinary unit climbs from level 1 to level 3. The doubling therefore pays most for a board of merged, expensive units. That same board is the one you least want to sell. Every monster Fate sells is gone from your board, so you must replace them before you press Battle. The sale gold pays for that rebuild, and the extra shop rank and the 8 free rerolls help you find the replacements.
Glamour Potion only pays when you sell. The +30 goes into each unit's bonus Sell Value. You get no gold until you sell that unit. One sale covers the $10 price, but buying Glamour still costs the day's Item use.
Fate pays each unit's normal sell value plus one extra base sell value. A Glamour bonus appears once in the normal sale, not again in the added base amount. Do not budget for that bonus twice.
A unit with no sell value stays worth $0. Monsters from
Summon Potion and
Legendary Potion have no sell value. Glamour skips them by its own text. Do not count them toward a Fate payout either. If you sell one, you get back a slot but no gold.
What do the copy, shiny, rarity and type Potions risk?
These Potions trade control for power. Read what each one picks at random.
- Random units.
Summon Potion gives a random Common, and it needs an empty team or bench slot even if the new unit could merge.
Legendary Potion fills every open slot with random Legendaries; it does not replace or sell the units you already have. You choose neither the species nor the types. The Legendary Potion fills your bench too. With all ten slots taken, a bought unit that cannot merge at once goes into overflow, and you cannot reroll, lock or fight until you make room. To make room you must sell a unit, and selling one of these Legendaries returns no gold. - A target by price.
Mushroom Potion takes a lowest-priced monster on the shelf, chosen at random when several share that price. It raises that monster's level by one and refills the shelf slot. If one offer is clearly cheapest, you know the result before you buy. If you buy a cheaper offer first, the Potion takes the next cheapest one. - Shiny is a different entry, not a bonus. Shiny forms have their own stats and ability values. There is no single multiplier. For example, normal
Celestia disables Ongoing monsters in its row on both teams, while Shiny Celestia targets only the enemies in that row.
Shiny Potion picks its target at random.
Glimmer Potion makes every offer on the shelf shiny, so you choose which shiny you buy. A merged unit turns out shiny if even one of its copies was shiny, so a Glimmer copy passes that form on. Compare the two entries on the unit's page before you buy. - Type Potions only work on eligible units. Mini Rainbow and Rainbow add a type only to monsters with 2 or fewer types. A monster that already has 3 types is not a valid target. These two Potions refund their Item use only when they work. The shop greys out an Item that would do nothing. Without an eligible unit, the type Potion is not a useful purchase; with one, a successful type grant refunds the use. An added type stays through later merges and transformations, so a bad roll is permanent on that unit.
- When an extra type helps. It helps effects that count types or target them.
Prismagon gains Damage for each unique type on your team. - When an extra type hurts. It can break a condition.
Kaleidoscope only speeds up monsters that share no type with an ally.
Three shop procedures
Stabilise a weak board
- Look at the first shop before you reroll. The Potion is only there.
- With empty slots,
Summon Potion adds a level 2 unit for $10.
Legendary Potion fills all open slots for $5, but you get random units that can never be sold for gold.
Growth Potion gives each of your monsters a small amount of Damage, Poison or Burn for $1, so it is worth more the more monsters you own.- If gold is the problem, take
Gold Potion, or
Blood Potion once you have lost at least 2 lives. - With
Mini Rainbow Potion,
Rainbow Potion or
Portal Potion, buy it first. When it works, the use comes back for another Item.
Find an eligible merge
- Write down each species you hold below level 3 and the copies it still lacks. Reaching level 2 takes three level 1 copies; reaching level 3 takes a pair of level 2 copies.
Swoonet is the exception and merges from two copies at each step. - Once you own a species at level 3, normal rolls stop offering it, and ordinary merging cannot take it further. Spend no Potion on copies of such a unit unless it is Swoonet, which normal rolls still offer and which keeps merging.
Mirror Potion rolls a shop of only your own species. It is the most direct way to find a missing copy. Its special shelf does not apply the normal owned-level exclusion, so an owned level 3 species can appear.
Mushroom Potion fits when the cheapest offer is a species you already hold at level 2. For a level 1 shelf copy, the Potion raises it to level 2 before granting it. That copy can then merge with your existing level 2 copy. It does not complete a set of level 1 copies. It needs an empty team or bench slot even if the copy would merge at once, so free a slot first.
Glimmer Potion fits when the shelf already shows the copy you will buy and that species' shiny entry is better for your board, because the shiny copy makes the merged unit shiny.- If all 10 slots are full, buy only a copy that completes a merge at once. Otherwise the unit goes into overflow, as described above. Each merge also gives you a trinket gift.
Consider a full board replacement
- Ask whether the board can still win. If it can, skip
Fate Potion. - Count your board's sell value before you buy Fate. Do not count units with no sell value, and remember that only the base value doubles.
- After Fate, spend the gold, the 8 free rerolls and the higher shop rank on new units to replace the ones it sold before you press Battle.
- The
Legendary Potion is the other path. It fills only empty slots, so a full replacement means selling units first at their normal value. You then hold units that return no gold when you sell them. - Fate and the Legendary Potion solve different problems. Choose between the offers you actually see; do not budget for a specific Potion to appear on a later day.
What does the ranked data say about the Witch?
In the ranked window 6 Nov 2026 to 19 Nov 2026, on Balance 27, the Witch appears in 3,910 observations. Her pick share is 7.1%, her win rate 15.6%, and her place by win rate 18. How to read stats explains what counts as an observation.
The Witch is picked more often than
Chemist.
Chemist still has the higher ranked win rate, so a popular trainer is not necessarily a strong one.
Show the numbers as a table
| Witch | Value | Sample |
|---|---|---|
| Rounds 1-4 | 15.6% | 3,910 observations |
| Rounds 5-8 | 15.6% | 3,910 observations |
| Rounds 9-12 | 15.6% | 3,910 observations |
| Rounds 13+ | 15.6% | 3,910 observations |
The ranked data records your trainer and your units, not the Potions you bought. It cannot show which Potion wins more, so every Potion recommendation above comes from catalog effects. The trinket data in the comps view covers only part of the runs. Raw counts from it do not rank the best choices either.
What changed in 1.5.1, and where to read more
Neither the Witch nor any Potion changed in 1.5.1. The patch touched gifts instead.
Fool's Gold was already kept out of Gift Items as a drawback trinket, and 1.5.1 puts
Plain Lure,
Sweet Lure and
Link Cable in that group too. As a result,
Burglar never takes one of those three as its bonus pick. With Burglar, a trinket gift also shows at most one drawback trinket. You can still pick that one yourself; only the extra steal skips it.
The 1.5.1 patch page covers the other changes.
For every Item's full entry, use Items. For the shop slots, rerolls, locks and merge exclusions, use Monster pool & shop. To compare the Witch with the other trainers before a run, read choosing a trainer.
